Home / NEWS / A low emission value does not automatically constitute BAT.A low emission value is a data point.

A low emission value does not automatically constitute BAT.A low emission value is a data point.

Posted on

A low emission value does not automatically constitute BAT.
A low emission value is a data point.

A BAT-AEL is a regulatory conclusion.

There must be evidence between the two.

In the Sevilla Process, installation data help shape BAT, BAT-AELs and environmental performance levels. These can later become binding requirements for an entire industrial sector.

The tempting assumption? Lower emissions mean better environmental performance.
But the assessment need to be broader.

IED 2.0 calls for consideration of overall environmental performance: emissions, water, energy, resources, waste, circularity, decarbonisation and cross-media effects.

Before turning a measured value into a regulatory conclusion, five questions matter:


1️⃣ What does “best” mean?
Minimising one parameter may increase energy use, resource consumption or environmental impacts elsewhere. The overall balance matters.

2️⃣ What does a low value actually prove?
It may reflect effective treatment — or simply very low substance input. Without process and input data, the number alone tells us little.

3️⃣ Is the emission really lower?
Concentration is not pollutant load.
Less wastewater can mean higher concentrations while total emissions fall. Concentration alone can therefore lead to the wrong conclusion.

4️⃣ How robust and representative are the data?
A broad dataset can shrink dramatically once installations are grouped by comparable processes, inputs and techniques.
Sometimes only a handful of values remain. Sometimes only one.
Can those values support a sector-wide BAT-AEL?
Representativeness, statistical robustness and uncertainty determine whether that conclusion is scientifically defensible.

5️⃣ What explains the better result?
Precipitation, scrubbing, filtration and evaporation are established techniques.
If installations using them support significantly lower BAT-AELs, we need to understand what they actually do differently.

The path from measurement to BAT requires process context, comparability, demonstrated emission reduction and a technical explanation — supported by robust data and an assessment of overall environmental performance.
Environmental ambition needs a sound evidence base.

If a numerical value is to become legally binding for an entire sector, the evidence supporting it must be at least as robust as the precision with which that value is written into law.

Top